Last night, a guy in New Hampshire who confused Bellingham for Seattle tried to tell me he understood our City Council races better than I do. His take, lifted directly from national ideological groups, had to be more accurate than mine after living here for 13 years, knowing the district, watching the players in action, and participating in the process.
Today, I was accused (by a man) of mansplaining a candidate’s views to him because he preferred his explanation to mine. I offered counterexamples that undermined his claims, and it’s much easier to dismiss the evidence than rethink your conclusions. I walked the candidate’s dog for a year and have known the candidate for a few years. I’ve discussed local issues with them. I know their spouse and the security code to their home. I have no evidence that this other man knows anything more about the candidate than he can Google.
——————————–
The way politics has been demonized and political science bastardized is ruining us.
***THIS IS HOW YOU LOSE ELECTIONS!***
It’s how Hillary’s campaign manager was convinced that his data models in New York City knew more about Michigan than his staffers in Michigan. This is how Transit Blog fanboys convince themselves that the passage of ST3 (in a presidential year) means Tim Eyman can’t possibly win a 3rd victory for $30 car tabs in 20 years (in an odd-numbered year).
Reality matters. Facts matter. Experience and expertise matter. The superficial, simplistic, canned answers that you like for whatever reason, that are convenient for you no matter the evidence or real life experiences of people on the ground, must be the dependent variable; not the fixed one. It’s especially hypocritical when the people who do this present themselves as “pro-science” (e.g. vaccination, climate change). When your hypothesis is damaged by contradictory evidence, your hypothesis is what needs to change–not ignoring, dismissing, or minimizing the evidence.
If you want to know how Ohioans are feeling, you HAVE to talk to OHIOANS. If you want to know how black people are affected by gentrification, you HAVE to listen to BLACK PEOPLE. If you want to anticipate the needs of Alzheimer’s caregivers, you HAVE to ask ALZHEIMER’S CAREGIVERS. Nothing about us without us.
This smugness, moral superiority, and alternate reality shit is seriously harmful; not just surreal. It’s why the Tim Eymans and Donald Trumps of America keep winning elections. We, or our allies, are enabling them. STOP IT.